I remember hearing the true origin of santa claus being based on a russian, european or middleeastern saint named saint nicholas who would give out gifts or money to the needy, many. And where do all those santas in department store grottoes come from. A lot of children think that, because they arent ready to be a santa yet, but you are. Praise for does santa exista philosophical investigation a witty, provocative, and profound exploration of reality, meaning, morality, and yes, santa claus. Imagined by a gan generative adversarial network stylegan2 dec 2019 karras et al. The mystery of who really wrote the most celebrated yuletide poem of all time, the night before christmas hardcover by carlo devito email or call for price. Help your kid brother feel better by crafting a counterargument in this holiday version of a persuasive essay. If satan exists but is not interested in humans, many are cautious or even fearful without reason. Please make doubly sure there are no innocent children peeking over your shoulder right now. The huffington post kaplans deadpan style lets you read this as a serious philosophical treatisebut you can also take it as a welldone farce.
I already read some of his books and his teachings. When your child asks if theres really a santa, its important to think carefully about what he is really asking. Kaplans investigation into the ontology of santa claus is erudite, readable and exceedingly funny. Eric kaplan, a coexecutive producer of the big bang theory, wrote a humorous philosophical investigation into the existence of santa called does santa exist. A humorous philosophical investigation into the existence of santa from a co executive producer of the big bang theorythe perfect stocking. He lives on north pole along with his wife, elves and reindeers. And if he does, how does he manage the seemingly impossible task of delivering presents to the worlds christmascelebrating good little girls and boys in a single chilly december night. Elves help him to process requests of millions of children who write letters to santa every year requesting for toys and other wishes, to help him determine whether these children have been good or bad, to fulfill the wishes of all good children and make requested toys for them. Ive read this book many times over the years and while its definitely not an easy bedtime read theres a lot happening on each and every page it is a book that young children can find something of interest in on every page. Npr coverage of does santa exist a philosophical investigation by eric kaplan. The question has stirred the imagination and emotions of much of the earths population and. Nicholas and the holiday traditions, such as giftgiving, inspired by him.
Heres what scientists say about life on other planets. Of course not thats why he created the cia christmas intelligence agency to train elves to spy on children. And an almostprofessional philosopher like kaplan he also is a comedy writer isnt going to come to a conclusion on such an important question as does santa exist. In a way, the title question of the book does santa exist. Praise for does santa exist a philosophical investigation a witty. Yes, virginia, there is a santa claus is a phrase from an editorial called is there a santa claus. Matt groening, creator of the simpsons and futurama and author of life in hell exceptionally interesting. The editorial appeared in the september 21, 1897, edition of the new york sun and has since become part of popular christmas folklore in the united states. Does santa exist a philosophical investigation kindle edition by. We were talking the whole way about santa claus and how great it would be if he really did exist. There are some things we dearly believe in that are not universally acknowledged as real. All of us want to believe hes coming to visit on christmas eve. Metaphysics isnt ordinarily much of a laughing matter.
Nick becomes a deeply insightful, laughoutloud discussion of the way some things exist but may not really be therejust like santa and his reindeer. Following the logic of the twoslit experiment, it is perfectly possible for him to visit all the good children of the world simultaneously, provided that he does so unseen. Does santa exist a philosophical investigation and millions of other books are available for instant access. Miles has been coming back from school talking about christmas and santa claus lao ren in chinese which literally means old man. But in the hands of acclaimed comedy writer and scholar eric kaplan, a search for the truth about old st. Here are the answers to those questions your children ask you about the proof of santas existence. Why 7 experts are convinced alien life might really exist. This minnesota teacher found an answer that captures the christmas spirit.
But, there is a short answer to the question where does santa claus live. Santa is really the only cultural icon we have whos male, does not carry a gun, and is all about peace, joy, giving, and caring for other people. Author harold myra was ceo of christianity today international for 32 years, and his christian perspective informs the storytelling. Posted on october 17, 2014 by sean carroll theres a claim out there one that is about 95% true, as it turns out that if you pick a wikipedia article at random, then click on the first nontrivial link, and keep clicking on the first link. Yes, virginia, santa claus does exist in all of us. Does your child in fact want the truth or does she want reassurance that it.
There really is a santa claus history of saint nicholas. Luckily, there exists a bevy of books that uncover the myth beneath. A humorous philosophical investigation into the existence of santa from a coexecutive producer of the big bang theorythe perfect stocking. How santa really works is a fun, engaging book that details the truth behind everything youve ever wanted to know about santa and christmas. Even after we outgrow the jolly fellow, the essential paradox persists. Eric kaplans son had a zoo trip canceled because one mom worried about reindeerinduced questions. Santa claus, also known as father christmas, saint nicholas, saint nick, kris kringle. Convince others of your answer to the question, does santa. Does santa exist a philosophical investigation by eric kaplan. Its like lifestyles of the rich and famous with him.
One christmas eve about 35 years ago, while i was in my teens, i was in a car with my parents, returning home very late at night. In this extract from his new book, big bang theory writer eric. He is a deep soul, an intellectual master, and a brilliant communicator of the subtleties of the intersections between faith and logic. Back in 1897, an 8yearold girl named virginia ohanlon wrote to a newspaper editor to ask a simple question does santa claus really exist. Scientists have offered a clue on the existence of santa claus by dating a bone said to belong to st nicholas to the same century in which he died. Tammi tells the author, eric kaplan, that her son, schyler, cant be friends with his son, ari, because ari would tell schyler that santa doesnt exist. His argument was that father christmas would not be able to climb. Kaplans investigation into the ontology of santa claus is erudite, readable and. But it turns out that he really does think that people embrace this contradiction we. I cant say im pleased with your new book, does santa exist. Santa is really the only cultural icon we have whos male, does not carry a gun, and is. As their first act as a santa, the child must choose someone they know, find out something that person needs, and secretly wrap and deliver that gift.
Help your child defend jolly old saint nicholas with this persuasive essay exercise. Richard dawkins boasts that he tried to tell a sixyearold child that father christmas didnt exist. Nick becomes a deeply insightful, laughoutloud discussion of the way some things exist but may not really be there. The short answer, in every way that matters, is yes, santa claus is real. Santa has been described as a positive male cultural icon. When this happens, reassure your kids that the story of santa is just one way among many to celebrate. Well, if satan does not exist, those who accept him as real are misled. For many kids, their friends or siblings will break the news to them that santa isnt real. Here is a list of scientific breakthroughs, that can put your mind at rest, so you can stop running around trying to be santa. It is the most reprinted newspaper editorial in the english language. But ill admit that the notion of beliefs calling out and not getting a response from the things that actually exist appealed to me.
Why we teach our children to believe in santa claus. Thats part of the magic for me, especially in a culture where weve become so commercialized and hooked into manufactured icons. At first, letters addressed to santa or the north pole would mostly go to the dead letter office dlo, as they were written to someone who, spoiler alert, does not exist. Santa claus has homes all around the world lucky elf. This causes eric to be concerned that tammi is sacrificing the childrens friendship for a belief. These are the questions that underlie an entertaining and thoughtprovoking new book by eric kaplan. My son got cancer and i thought that was really bad. Using buddhism as his primary source, kaplan explains how selfcontradiction could be embraced to justify both the existence of santa and his nonexistence. Santa claus is a legend or mythical person based on an actual human being who lived in ancient times.
Does santa exist a philosophical investigation by eric. As we pulled into the driveway of our housethere he was, tiptoeing in the snow inbetween two houses across the street. Then his existence is affirmed by friends, books, tv and movies. How santa really works is a true scoop on how santa does what he does so well, brilliantly conceived by alan snow. The grumpy elf proves santa claus does exist and is for real. Some of your friends might have even told you that there is no santa. Uh oh, some mean kids have made an argument that santa doesnt exist. If santa claus really exists wouldnt he bring presents to all the children including those in war zones or those whove been kidnapped etc. And if you still dont believe me, here are nine proofs to prove that point like the point on my pointy shoes.
Thats a lot of research and information you gave, however, santa clause does not currently exist. In mysticism, paradox is a fundamental tool for understanding how we exist. So, you can say that santa claus exist since saint basil was a real person and saint but does not exist since the known santa claus is a fake. As a father, it is a new set of questions and decisions.
1047 1598 119 568 1333 385 161 65 1587 1279 929 718 368 346 1136 518 897 234 366 870 208 274 1295 1113 1246 24 378 382 1455 312